Glucosamine for joints & osteoarthritis in martial arts: Update of the evidence - not much support for general use
– This article came from Pharmacy E-Bulletin by
Chris Alderman at South Australia Health and is based on work by Anna McClure, Clinical Pharmacy Co-ordinator, RGH.
In an earlier Pharmacy E-bulletin (Glucosamine for osteoarthritis, 5(1) February 2002), available evidence at the time provided support for the use of glucosamine in treating pain and immobility associated with OA and suggested a potential role in disease-modification. Since this time, further studies and meta-analyses have failed to fully consolidate this position.
In February 2008, a NICE Clinical Guidance was published on the topic of osteoarthritis management in adults and included recommendations on the role of glucosamine. The authors noted difficulties in comparing the evidence from trials due to differences
between the products employed by the study populations, variable patient characteristics, and the use of analgesia at the time of pain and function assessment in the trials. Overall, the trials that used glucosamine sulfate (rather than hydrochloride) as a single dose of 1500 mg (rather than divided doses) showed a small benefit over placebo for treatment of knee OA. Evidence to support the efficacy of glucosamine hydrochloride suggests that this formulation may not be as effective in relieving pain as glucosamine sulfate. The NICE Guidance concludes that “the use of glucosamine products is not recommended for the treatment of osteoarthritis” and prescribers on the UK’s NHS are discouraged from prescribing any glucosamine preparations for patients with OA.
In the absence of strong evidence in support of glucosamine, a judicious approach is warranted. The efficacy argument needs to be balanced with financial cost and adverse effects. In general, glucosamine preparations are well tolerated with gastrointestinal upset being the most commonly reported adverse effect. Caution and increased monitoring are advised in the setting of concurrent warfarin administration (due to reports of INR fluctuations) and patients with diabetes (due to possible effects on glucose metabolism).
While the effectiveness remains unclear, it appears glucosamine is a relatively safe treatment option for people with OA to trial.
In summary, the results from studies of glucosamine are controversial. Based on the evidence to hand, a suggested approach for those patients wishing to try (or continue taking) glucosamine would be to use the sulfate salt, take a single daily dose of 1500mg, to use it for OA of the knee and to perform a trial of therapy, reviewing the effects of glucosamine after 2-3 months compared with their pain before commencement.
Related article of a later date: Another larger clinical study shows glucosamine has no effect on joint pain